Modern ligament reconstruction procedures, especially ACL reconstruction surgery, require strong and reliable graft fixation systems. Two of the most commonly used fixation methods are interference screws and suspensory fixation systems.

Both techniques are widely used in sports medicine and arthroscopic surgery, but they differ in biomechanics, fixation principles, surgical technique, and clinical applications.

Understanding the differences between interference screw fixation and suspensory fixation helps surgeons choose the most appropriate solution for each patient and reconstruction technique.


What is an Interference Screw?

An interference screw is a fixation implant inserted between the graft and bone tunnel to compress and stabilize the graft during ligament reconstruction procedures.

Interference screws are commonly used in:

  • ACL reconstruction
  • PCL reconstruction
  • Tendon fixation procedures
  • Bone-tendon-bone graft fixation
  • Hamstring graft fixation

These screws may be manufactured from:

  • Titanium
  • PEEK
  • Bioabsorbable materials

How Interference Screw Fixation Works

The graft is inserted into the bone tunnel, and the screw is advanced between the graft and tunnel wall.

This creates:

  • Direct graft compression
  • Immediate fixation stability
  • Strong tendon-to-bone contact

The fixation mechanism relies on compression inside the tunnel.


Advantages of Interference Screws

Strong Aperture Fixation

Interference screws provide fixation close to the joint line, reducing graft micromotion.


Excellent Tendon-to-Bone Contact

Compression inside the tunnel improves biological healing conditions.


Commonly Used Technique

Interference screw fixation is one of the most established methods in ligament reconstruction surgery.


Suitable for Multiple Graft Types

Can be used with:

  • Hamstring grafts
  • BTB grafts
  • Quadriceps tendon grafts

Limitations of Interference Screws

Tunnel Enlargement Risk

Improper placement or excessive stress may contribute to tunnel widening.


Graft Damage Risk

Insertion technique is critical to avoid graft laceration during screw advancement.


Bone Quality Dependency

Fixation strength may be reduced in poor bone quality.


What is Suspensory Fixation?

Suspensory fixation systems stabilize the graft using cortical fixation outside the bone tunnel.

These systems commonly use:

  • Buttons
  • Loops
  • Adjustable loop devices

Suspensory fixation is especially common on the femoral side during ACL reconstruction.


How Suspensory Fixation Works

The fixation device passes through the tunnel and locks against the cortical bone surface.

The graft remains suspended inside the tunnel while tension is maintained through the fixation system.


Advantages of Suspensory Fixation

High Initial Fixation Strength

Modern suspensory systems provide excellent biomechanical stability.


Preserves Graft Integrity

There is no direct screw compression against the graft.


Adjustable Tensioning Options

Adjustable loop systems allow intraoperative graft tension optimization.


Useful in Soft Tissue Grafts

Particularly effective in hamstring tendon reconstructions.


Limitations of Suspensory Fixation

Potential Micromotion

Suspensory fixation may allow slight graft motion inside the tunnel.


Tunnel Widening Concerns

Micromotion may contribute to tunnel enlargement in some cases.


Longer Distance to Joint Line

Fixation occurs outside the tunnel aperture rather than directly at the joint line.


Interference Screw vs Suspensory Fixation

Fixation Principle

Interference Screw

  • Compression fixation
  • Aperture fixation
  • Direct tendon-to-bone contact

Suspensory Fixation

  • Cortical suspension
  • Adjustable fixation options
  • Indirect fixation mechanism

Biomechanical Considerations

Interference Screw

  • Strong aperture fixation
  • Reduced graft motion

Suspensory Fixation

  • High pullout strength
  • Adjustable graft tensioning

Common Clinical Applications

Interference Screw

  • Tibial fixation
  • BTB grafts
  • Hybrid fixation techniques

Suspensory Fixation

  • Femoral fixation
  • Hamstring grafts
  • All-inside ACL techniques

Hybrid Fixation Techniques

Many modern ACL reconstruction procedures combine both systems.

Common combination:

  • Femoral suspensory fixation
  • Tibial interference screw fixation

This hybrid approach aims to maximize fixation stability and biological healing.


Material Options

Both fixation systems are available in different materials:

Titanium

  • High mechanical strength
  • Permanent fixation

PEEK

  • MRI compatibility
  • Radiolucent structure

Bioabsorbable Materials

  • Gradual absorption
  • Reduced permanent implant presence

Choosing the Right Fixation Method

The optimal fixation method depends on:

  • Graft type
  • Surgical technique
  • Bone quality
  • Surgeon preference
  • Tunnel size
  • Rehabilitation protocol

No single system is ideal for every procedure.


Conclusion

Interference screws and suspensory fixation systems are both highly effective solutions for ligament reconstruction procedures. Each method offers unique biomechanical and clinical advantages depending on the surgical indication and graft selection.

Modern arthroscopic surgery often combines these systems to achieve strong fixation, improved healing conditions, and successful long-term outcomes.

Orthosyn Medikal provides interference screws, suspensory fixation systems, and arthroscopy solutions designed for modern sports medicine and orthopedic reconstruction procedures.

interference-screw-vs-suspensory-fixation-acl-fixation-guide---orthosyn